Displacing Indigenous
Peoples
1. Learning Objectives
After reading these notes, you will be able to:
2. Introduction β The Big Picture
- Many rivers, towns, and places in the USA and Canada have native names β e.g., Ohio, Mississippi, Seattle (USA), Saskatchewan (Canada), Wollongong and Parramatta (Australia).
- From the 1840s, native peoples were studied by anthropologists in America.
- Today, visitors to museums can see galleries of ‘native art’. The new National Museum of the American Indian in USA has been curated by American Indians themselves.
3. European Imperialism
πΊοΈ Different Forms of Colonial Control
- South Asia (India): Trading companies like the East India Company made themselves into political powers β defeated local rulers, annexed territories, retained the administrative system, and collected taxes. Later, they built railways, excavated mines, and established plantations.
- Africa: Europeans first only traded on the coast. Only in the late 19th century did they venture into the interior. Then several European countries agreed to divide up Africa as colonies among themselves.
- Settler Colonies: The word ‘settler’ is used for the Dutch in South Africa, the British in Ireland, New Zealand and Australia, and the Europeans in America. The official language in these colonies was English (except in Canada, where French is also official).
‘Canada’ β From kanata (= ‘village’ in Huron-Iroquois language, heard by explorer Jacques Cartier in 1535).
‘Australia’ β 16th-century name for land in the Great Southern Ocean (austral = Latin for ‘south’).
‘New Zealand’ β Named by Tasman of Holland, who first sighted these islands in 1642 (zee = Dutch for ‘sea’).
4. North America β The Native Peoples
πΉ Origins of Native Peoples
- The earliest inhabitants of North America came from Asia over 30,000 years ago on a land-bridge across the Bering Straits.
- During the last Ice Age (10,000 years ago), they moved further south.
- The oldest artefact found in America β an arrow-point β is 11,000 years old.
- Population started to increase about 5,000 years ago when the climate became more stable.
ποΈ Life of Native Peoples (Before Europeans)
- They lived in bands, in villages along river valleys. They ate fish and meat, and cultivated vegetables and maize.
- They went on long journeys in search of bison (wild buffalo). From the 17th century, they started riding horses (bought from Spanish settlers).
- They only killed as many animals as needed β they never over-hunted.
- They did not practice extensive agriculture, so they did not produce a surplus β and thus did not develop kingdoms and empires as in Central and South America.
- Land was not seen as something to ‘own’ β they were content with what the land gave them.
- An important feature of their tradition: making formal alliances and exchanging gifts. Goods were obtained as gifts, not by buying.
- They spoke numerous languages (not written down). They believed time moved in cycles.
- They were skilled craftspeople and wove beautiful textiles. They could read the land β understanding climates and landscapes in the way literate people read written texts.
Hunted bison;
only what they needed
Villages in river
valleys; grew maize
Goods obtained
as gifts, not bought
Many languages;
history passed orally
Land was shared,
not ‘owned’
Beautiful textiles;
reading the land
American Indian / Amerind / Amerindian β Native peoples of North, South America and the Caribbean
First Nations peoples β Organised native groups recognised by the Canadian government (from the 1980s)
Indigenous people β People belonging naturally to a place
Native American β The term now commonly used for the indigenous people of the Americas
‘Red Indian’ β The brown-complexioned people whose land Columbus mistook for India
5. Encounters with Europeans
πͺ What Europeans Gave the Natives
- Blankets, iron vessels (used in place of clay pots), guns (useful supplement to bows and arrows).
- Alcohol β something natives had never known before. They became addicted to it. The Europeans used this to dictate terms of trade.
- In return, Europeans acquired an addiction to tobacco from the natives.
π¦ Different Views of Trade
- To the natives, goods exchanged with Europeans were gifts given in friendship.
- To Europeans, fish and furs were commodities β to be sold for a profit in Europe.
- The natives were confused by the fact that Europeans sometimes gave a lot, sometimes very little β they had no concept of a ‘market’ in faraway Europe.
- Natives were also saddened by the greed of Europeans who slaughtered hundreds of beavers β natives feared the animals would take revenge.
π Settlers Move Inland
- From the 17th century, religious refugees (Protestants and Catholics persecuted in Europe) came to America to begin a new life.
- As long as there was vacant land, this was fine β but gradually Europeans moved further inland near native villages.
- They used iron tools to cut down forests and lay out farms.
- Natives and Europeans saw forests differently β natives identified hidden tracks; Europeans imagined forests cut down and replaced by cornfields.
- Thomas Jefferson’s dream: A country populated by Europeans with small farms. Natives who grew crops only for their own needs and did not ‘own’ the land were seen by Jefferson as ‘uncivilised’.
6. Mutual Perceptions β How They Saw Each Other
πͺπΊ How Europeans Saw Natives
- In the 18th century, western Europeans defined ‘civilised’ people in terms of literacy, organised religion, and urbanism. Native Americans appeared ‘uncivilised’ to them.
- To some like French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, natives were to be admired as untouched by civilisation’s corruptions β the popular term was ‘the noble savage’.
- English poet William Wordsworth (who had never met a native American) described them as having limited powers of imagination and emotion.
- US President Thomas Jefferson (third president) called the native peoples an ‘unfortunate race’ and spoke of ‘justified extermination’ β words that would cause public outrage today.
πͺΆ How Natives Saw Europeans
- Many folk tales of natives mocked Europeans, describing them as greedy and deceitful β but told as imaginary stories so Europeans understood only much later.
- When the Hopi tribe saw Spanish Conquistadores covered in armour, they thought these were the ‘turtle brothers’ mentioned in their stone tablet prophecy β and went out with a welcoming handshake, only to receive a trinket.
- Natives were deeply troubled by European greed β especially the mass slaughter of beavers for fur trade.
Europeans β Fish and furs were commodities to sell for profit.
7. Native Peoples Lose Their Land
βοΈ The Cherokee Case β 1832
- The Cherokee tribe had made the most effort to learn English and understand the American way of life β yet they were not allowed the rights of citizens.
- US Chief Justice John Marshall (1832) declared the Cherokees were ‘a distinct community, occupying its own territory’ with sovereignty in certain matters.
- But President Andrew Jackson refused to honour this judgment and ordered the US Army to evict the Cherokees and drive them to the Great American Desert.
- Of the 15,000 people forced to march, over a quarter died along what became known as the ‘Trail of Tears’.
𦬠Clearing the Land
- Those who took native land justified it by saying natives did not use the land to its maximum β calling them ‘lazy’ and ‘uncivilised’.
- The prairies were cleared for farmland; wild bison were killed off by 1890, ending the natives’ centuries-old way of life.
- Natives were pushed westward and locked in small areas called ‘reservations’ β often land with which they had no earlier connection.
- Many tribes were forced to share the land of one tribe, causing quarrels between them.
- The US army crushed a series of native rebellions from 1865 to 1890. In Canada, armed revolts by the Metis (people of native-European descent) occurred from 1869 to 1885.
πΎ European Immigrants and Land
- European immigrants β from Britain, France, Germany, Sweden, Italy, and Poland β came eager to own land.
- They introduced crops like rice and cotton, cleared forests, and developed large-scale agriculture.
- To protect farms from wolves and mountain lions, these were hunted to extinction.
- Barbed wire (invented 1873) made Europeans feel totally secure on their large farms.
- In the hot southern states, African slaves were brought in for plantation work, since the climate was too harsh for Europeans to work outdoors.
- After protests, the slave trade was banned, but enslaved Africans in the USA remained enslaved. The American Civil War (1861β65) ended with the abolition of slavery.
π Population Data (For Exam Questions)
| Group | USA (1820) | Spanish America (1800) |
|---|---|---|
| Natives | 0.6 million | 7.5 million |
| Whites | 9.0 million | 3.3 million |
| Mixed Europeans | 0.1 million | 5.3 million |
| Blacks | 1.9 million | 0.8 million |
| Total | 11.6 million | 16.9 million |
8. Gold Rush and Growth of Industries
- In the 1840s, gold was found in California, USA β this led to the ‘Gold Rush’, when thousands of Europeans rushed to America hoping for quick fortune.
- This triggered the building of railway lines across the continent, for which thousands of Chinese workers were recruited.
- USA’s railway completed: 1870; Canada’s: 1885.
- Andrew Carnegie β a poor immigrant from Scotland who became one of the first millionaire industrialists of the USA β said: “The old nations creep on at a snail’s pace; the Republic thunders on at the speed of an express.”
- Industries developed in North America to manufacture railway equipment and produce machinery for large-scale farming.
- In 1860, the USA was an undeveloped economy. By 1890, it was the leading industrial power in the world.
- By 1890, bison had almost been exterminated, ending the centuries-old hunting life of the natives.
- In 1892, the USA’s continental expansion was complete β the entire area from Pacific to Atlantic was divided into states. The ‘frontier’ was gone.
- Within a few years, the USA set up its own colonies β in Hawaii and the Philippines. It had become an imperial power.
9. Constitutional Rights & Winds of Change β USA & Canada
π Things Begin to Improve β 1920s Onwards
- Meriam Report (1928): The survey The Problem of Indian Administration (directed by Lewis Meriam) painted a grim picture of the terrible conditions of native health and education in reservations.
- Indian Reorganisation Act (1934): A landmark law that gave natives in reservations the right to buy land and take loans.
- In the 1950sβ60s, US and Canadian governments thought of ending all special provisions for natives, hoping they would ‘join the mainstream’ (adopt European culture). But natives refused.
- Declaration of Indian Rights (1954): Native peoples accepted US citizenship β but only on the condition that their reservations would not be taken away and their traditions would not be interfered with.
- Canada (1969): Government announced it would ‘not recognise aboriginal rights’. Natives held well-organised demonstrations and debates.
- Canada’s Constitution Act (1982): Accepted the existing aboriginal and treaty rights of the natives. Many details remain to be worked out.
- Today, native peoples of both countries have been able to assert their right to their own cultures and, particularly in Canada, to their sacred lands.
π Important Dates β USA & Canada
10. Australia β The Aboriginal Peoples
π Key Facts About Australian Aborigines
- Past centuries were called the ‘Dreamtime’ β a concept difficult for Europeans to understand, as the distinction between past and present is blurred.
- In the late 18th century, there were between 350 and 750 native communities in Australia, each with its own language. Even today, 200 of these languages are still spoken.
- There is another large group of indigenous people in the north β the Torres Strait Islanders (the term ‘Aborigine’ is not used for them).
- Together, they make up 2.4% of Australia’s population (as of 2005).
- Australia is sparsely populated; most towns are along the coast because the central region is arid desert.
π’ Europeans Reach Australia β Timeline
π’ Impact on Aboriginal Peoples
- In the 19th and 20th centuries, nearly 90% of Aboriginal peoples died β from exposure to germs, loss of lands and resources, and battles against settlers.
- Initial encounters were friendly, but British feelings reversed sharply when Captain Cook was killed by a native (not in Australia, but in Hawaii). This single incident was used to justify subsequent violence.
- British settlers destroyed sacred places and cut down trees β behaviour the Daruk people found completely inexplicable.
- Some natives were employed in farms under conditions little different from slavery.
- Later, Chinese immigrants provided cheap labour β but fear of dependence on non-whites led the government to ban Chinese immigration.
- Till 1974, there was a ‘White Australia’ policy β a government policy to keep ‘non-white’ people out.
ποΈ Development of Australia β Timeline
11. Winds of Change β Australia
- From the 1970s, there was a growing eagerness to understand natives not as ‘anthropological curiosities’ but as communities with distinct cultures β unique ways of understanding nature, vast bodies of stories, textile, painting, and carving skills.
- The book Why Weren’t We Told? by Henry Reynolds condemned the practice of writing Australian history as though it had begun with Captain Cook’s ‘discovery’.
- University departments were set up to study native cultures; galleries of native art were added to art galleries; natives began writing their own life histories.
- From 1974, ‘multiculturalism’ became official Australian policy β giving equal respect to native cultures and to immigrant cultures from Europe and Asia.
- Australia realised (unlike USA, Canada, and New Zealand) it had no treaties with the natives. The government had always termed Australia terra nullius (= ‘belonging to nobody’).
- A long and painful history of children of mixed blood (native-European) being forcibly separated from their native families also came to light.
β Major Legal and Political Milestones β Australia
12. Quick Chapter Summary
From the 18th century, European settlers displaced native peoples in North America, Australia, and elsewhere β turning colonies into independent states where Europeans and Asians now form the majority.
Native peoples of North America arrived 30,000+ years ago. They lived in villages, hunted bison, wove textiles, had rich oral traditions β and saw land as something to use, not own.
Early encounters between Europeans and natives involved trade in fish and furs. Europeans introduced alcohol, which natives became addicted to β and Europeans used this to control terms of trade.
Europeans saw natives as ‘uncivilised’. Natives saw Europeans as greedy and deceitful. The key difference: natives saw goods as gifts; Europeans saw them as commodities for profit.
Natives were forced to sign treaties giving up land at very low prices. The Cherokee’s ‘Trail of Tears’ (1832) is a famous example β President Jackson defied the Supreme Court to evict them.
By 1890, bison were nearly exterminated. Natives were confined to ‘reservations’ β often moved again if minerals were found there. The US Army crushed all native rebellions by 1890.
The Gold Rush (1840s) and subsequent industrialisation made the USA the world’s leading industrial power by 1890. Chinese labour built railways; African slaves worked the southern plantations.
In Australia, Aboriginal peoples had been there for 40,000+ years. Most early settlers were deported convicts. Nearly 90% of Aboriginal peoples died from disease and displacement in the 19thβ20th centuries.
The Meriam Report (1928) and Indian Reorganisation Act (1934) began improvements in the USA. Canada’s Constitution Act (1982) recognised aboriginal and treaty rights.
Australia’s Mabo case (1992) overturned the concept of terra nullius. A ‘National Sorry Day’ (1999) marked the public apology for separating children from their families. From 1974, multiculturalism became official policy.
13. Important Terms to Remember
14. Comparison β USA & Australia
| Aspect | USA / Canada | Australia |
|---|---|---|
| Native peoples | Native Americans (Amerindians, First Nations) | Aboriginal peoples & Torres Strait Islanders |
| Arrival of natives | 30,000+ years ago via Bering Straits from Asia | 40,000+ years ago from New Guinea |
| First European contact | 1497 (Cabot); 1607 (British colony in Virginia) | 1606 (Dutch); 1770 (Captain Cook); 1788 (Penal colony) |
| Type of early settlers | Religious refugees, merchants, younger sons | Mainly convicts deported from England |
| Treaties with natives | Yes β though often violated | No treaties; land termed terra nullius |
| Key reform law | Indian Reorganisation Act (1934); Constitution Act Canada (1982) | Mabo case (1992); National Sorry Day (1999) |
| Key change in history | 1960s: Natives encouraged to write own histories | 1968: Stanner’s ‘Great Australian Silence’ lecture |
15. Important Questions for Exam
π Short Answer (2β3 marks)
- What did the ‘frontier’ mean to the Americans? (The shifting western boundary of settlement β as it moved west, natives were forced to move back. By 1892 it was gone.)
- Why was the history of Australian native peoples left out of history books? (Historians wrote as though Australian history began with Captain Cook. This was called the ‘Great Australian Silence’.)
- What were ‘reservations’? Why were natives often moved from them too? (Small areas of land assigned to natives β often moved again if minerals or oil were found there.)
- What was terra nullius? (Latin for ‘belonging to nobody’ β Australia’s legal fiction that the land belonged to no one before the British came.)
- What was the Trail of Tears? (The forced march of 15,000 Cherokee people in 1838 β over a quarter died.)
π Long Answer (5β6 marks)
- Discuss the ‘Mutual Perceptions’ of Europeans and Native Americans β how did each side see the other, and how did they view nature differently?
- How did native peoples of North America lose their land? Discuss with specific examples.
- Describe the changes brought by the Gold Rush and Industrialisation on North America and its native peoples.
- Write a note on the ‘Winds of Change’ for native peoples in Australia. What legal and political changes took place from the 1970s onwards?
- Compare the experiences of native peoples in the USA and Australia under European colonialism.
